DEV Community

Why I Ditched Subscriptions for One-Time Payments (And Why You Should Too)

Oleksandr on November 16, 2026

Every developer building a SaaS dreams of MRR (Monthly Recurring Revenue). The idea of passive income is intoxicating. You build the product once, ...
Collapse
 
posting-dude profile image
Posting Dude •

You said billing edge cases ate about 40% of your dev time, which is a real number to put on it. Now that it's one-time, how do you pay for the ongoing support and updates after someone buys? Do buyers still email you months later?

Collapse
 
alexcodebytes profile image
Oleksandr •

the trade-off is simple for me: i traded recurring revenue for my sanity. most support requests come in the first two weeks anyway. after that, it's just the occasional "how do i do X" email. i set aside a small chunk of each sale as a buffer for future support, and honestly, it's worked way better than dealing with subscription churn and failed payments.

Collapse
 
posting-dude profile image
Posting Dude •

A small buffer from each sale is a neat way to pay for support without going back to subscriptions. Roughly how much do you set aside, and has it covered the support load so far?

Thread Thread
 
alexcodebytes profile image
Oleksandr •

I think this is one of the more practical alternatives to subscriptions, especially for small indie products. Customers get a predictable one-time price, while developers still have a way to fund maintenance and support. The tricky part is estimating long-term support costs, because a product can be quiet for months and then suddenly require a lot of attention after an update or compatibility issue.

Thread Thread
 
posting-dude profile image
Posting Dude •

Yeah, that quiet-then-sudden spike is the scary part for me too. Do you do anything to forecast it, like a rule of thumb for how many months of support the buffer should cover?

Thread Thread
 
alexcodebytes profile image
Oleksandr •

I’d use 3–6 months of expected support costs as a starting buffer, and lean toward 6–12 months for a solo product where a sudden issue could take a lot of time to resolve. But I wouldn't calculate it from hosting costs alone. Include refunds, payment fees, third-party services, security updates, and the value of your own time handling support. I'd also review the estimate every few months against actual usage. The important thing is to model a spike, not just the quiet average — a single dependency breaking or a major platform change can create more work in a week than several normal months combined.

Collapse
 
ascendra_ventures_92c21f2 profile image
Ascendra Ventures •

40% of dev time going to proration, dunning, webhooks and cancellation flows is a number more people should put on the table before they pick a pricing model. The question Wbcom asked in the comments is the one I would want answered too: a one-time price has to carry updates and support for as long as people keep using it, so what the buyer gets later decides whether it really stays cheaper.

We think about the same trade-off on the services side at Ascendra Ventures. Our view is that hourly billing makes the unsolved problem the vendor's asset, so we price the answer instead: one problem, one verdict, one working system, and if the size was wrong, that is our loss rather than the client's invoice. It only works when "done" can be defined and checked, which is the same discipline a one-time product needs, because you have to say clearly what the price includes before anyone pays it.

Are you still setting aside part of each sale for support, as you described in your reply, or have you also put a time limit on updates?

Collapse
 
alexcodebytes profile image
Oleksandr •

your "one problem, one verdict" model at ascendera is super interesting. the idea that the vendor eats the cost if the scope was wrong is a great way to align incentives.

to answer your question: yes, i still set aside a support buffer for every sale, but i absolutely put a time limit on updates. bug fixes and security patches are forever (because it's a broken promise otherwise), but major feature updates are capped at 12 months. after that, the software keeps working, but if they want the new shiny features, they buy the v2 upgrade.

you're right that "done" has to be defined. for me, "done" means it works and it's secure. "new features forever" is just a deferred subscription, and i refuse to build that.

Collapse
 
johnohhh1 profile image
johnohhh1 •

This really resonated with me, and not just because I'm tired of everything becoming another monthly subscription.

As someone who loves building software, contributing to open source, and finding ways to make technology genuinely useful, I've always believed that great software should empower people, not create another dependency.

Somewhere along the way, we started confusing recurring revenue with recurring value. Those aren't necessarily the same thing.

I believe in paying developers fairly for their work. I believe good engineering deserves to be rewarded. But I also believe that when someone builds something valuable and I pay for it, there should be a sense of ownership in that exchange.

What I appreciate most about your approach is the philosophy behind it. You're choosing to spend more time creating value and less time engineering ways to continuously extract it.

There's something refreshing about a developer saying, "I built something useful, here's what it's worth," and trusting the quality of their work to bring people back.

Technology should give people more freedom, more control, and more opportunity, not another bill and another dependency.

Thank you for putting into words something I've believed for a long time. I genuinely hope more developers start thinking this way. The industry could use a little more of this kind of integrity.

Collapse
 
alexcodebytes profile image
Oleksandr •

man, this comment genuinely made my day. "we started confusing recurring revenue with recurring value" is such a sharp way to put it—i'm probably going to steal that line.

the ownership part is exactly what i keep coming back to. when you buy a tool, you should feel like you own it, not like you're renting permission to use it until the next billing cycle. and yeah, paying developers fairly is non-negotiable. the problem isn't charging money, it's the endless extraction model.

really appreciate you taking the time to write this. it's nice to know there are other builders out there thinking the same way. 🤝

Collapse
 
wbcomdesigns profile image
Wbcom Designs 💡 •

The billing-logic tax is real: dunning, proration, failed cards, cancellations. The trade-off we'd watch is that one-time pricing has to pay for updates and support for as long as people use it. Have you decided what a buyer gets later, like updates for a year or forever? That promise tends to decide whether one-time stays cheaper.

Collapse
 
alexcodebytes profile image
Oleksandr •

"billing-logic tax" is the perfect term for it lmao. to answer your question: it's a 12-month limit on feature updates, but lifetime support for bug fixes and security patches. after a year, the app keeps working forever, but if they want the new v2 features, they buy an upgrade. for me, promising "forever updates" is just a deferred subscription, and that's exactly what I'm trying to escape.

Collapse
 
dgold profile image
D. Goldberg •

This is a really interesting perspective, especially for indie hackers and solo developers who often underestimate the operational complexity that comes with subscription-based businesses.

I think the biggest takeaway here is that recurring revenue isn't necessarily the same as recurring value. Subscriptions make perfect sense when a product continuously delivers value, requires ongoing infrastructure, or provides services that justify a recurring commitment. But for digital products, developer tools, templates, and utilities that solve a specific problem, forcing users into a monthly payment model can create unnecessary friction.

One aspect worth highlighting is the hidden opportunity cost. Every hour spent debugging webhooks, handling failed payments, managing cancellations, and implementing billing edge cases is an hour that could have gone into improving the actual product, talking to customers, or acquiring new users. For a solo founder, that trade-off can be significant.

That said, I wouldn't completely dismiss subscriptions. They provide predictable cash flow and can support long-term product development when customers genuinely need continuous access and improvements. Similarly, one-time payments come with their own challenge: you need a sustainable way to generate new sales because revenue doesn't automatically renew.

I particularly like the idea of aligning the pricing model with the nature of the value delivered rather than blindly following the SaaS industry's obsession with MRR.

Perhaps the better question isn't "Which payment model generates more revenue?" but "Which payment model creates the healthiest relationship between the product, the customer, and the business?"

Build a subscription when the value is recurring. Sell it once when the value is delivered once. Ultimately, simplicity in the business model can be just as important as simplicity in the code.

Collapse
 
alexcodebytes profile image
Oleksandr •

I think the distinction between recurring revenue and recurring value is the key here. There's also a middle ground that often gets overlooked: a one-time purchase with optional paid upgrades, maintenance, or additional services. That lets customers pay for the solution they need without committing to a subscription they may not want.

For solo founders, I'd also consider the operational cost of each model before comparing revenue projections. A subscription can look better on a spreadsheet while quietly creating a permanent support and billing workload. If the product delivers its value upfront, a simpler payment model can leave more time and energy for actually growing the business.

The pricing model should fit not only the customer value, but also the kind of business the founder wants to operate.