Launch week for my little logic-puzzle game has been a blur of kind messages and sharp-eyed players, so here is something small in return — a puzzle of my own, written just for this post. No spoilers for the game in it; it stands alone.
Three neighbours — Ada, Ben and Cleo — are questioned about a missing prize pumpkin from the village fête. Each of them makes exactly one statement:
- Ada: "Ben took it."
- Ben: "I didn't take it."
- Cleo: "Ben is lying."
Exactly one of them is lying. Who took the pumpkin — and how do you know?
Leave your reasoning in the comments. I will post the solution tomorrow, and the clearest explanation gets a mention in the next devlog.
If you enjoy this sort of thing, Liar's Ledger is a solo game of pure deduction — every case is a web of statements, and exactly one of them is lying. You can play it in your browser or on the App Store. Links are in my profile.
Top comments (1)
Solution: Ben took the pumpkin.
Here's why: if Ada had taken it, then Ada's statement ('Ben took it') would be false, and Cleo's ('Ben is lying') would also be false — Ben told the truth when he said he didn't take it — so there would be two liars, not one. The same goes if Cleo had taken it. Only Ben taking it leaves exactly one liar: Ben himself, who says 'I didn't take it.'
Thanks to everyone who reasoned it out — the clearest explanation gets a mention in the next devlog.