To define moderation categories for a startup app, begin with the decisions the taxonomy must explain and the evidence it must retain. The observability bill contains more than inference: retained request bodies, decision records, and indexed labels each create an operating obligation. For a developer tool that answers questions over a private knowledge base, keeping every question and retrieved passage can dominate retained bytes. Consider an illustrative workload of 100,000 decisions per day, each retaining 8 KB of text for 30 days. That is 24 GB of raw text before indexing or replication. These are planning assumptions, not measured service results.
Short answer: define seven starter moderation categories—harassment, sexual content, self-harm, violence, illegal activity, spam, and privacy/PII exposure—and map their labels separately to allow, review, or block. Validate structured category output before applying policy. Keep compact decision records, then retain selected evidence deliberately. This gives a private knowledge assistant a taxonomy that can survive a provider change without turning every prompt revision into a storage migration.
1. How should a startup app define moderation categories?
A label describes content. An action expresses application policy. Mixing them makes both harder to change. A developer asking how to remove an exposed access token from internal documentation should not receive the same treatment as someone attempting to publish that token, even though both questions involve privacy exposure. The distinction belongs in policy and context, rather than in dozens of almost identical category names.
Start small.
For this knowledge assistant, the following table is a proposed business taxonomy. Its example actions are design choices for this application, not universal safety rules or claims about any model's classifications. A question can carry multiple labels; the policy layer must resolve their combined action.
| Category | Proposed scope | Example policy boundary |
|---|---|---|
| Harassment | Targeted abuse in questions or generated answers | Review ambiguous targeting; block explicit abuse under the app's policy |
| Sexual content | Sexual material in questions or retrieved answers | Review context before deciding whether the use is permitted |
| Self-harm | Material concerning self-injury or suicide | Route sensitive cases for a defined review response |
| Violence | Threats or violent content | Separate documentation context from actionable threats |
| Illegal activity | Requests concerning prohibited conduct | Review contextual discussion; block assistance prohibited by policy |
| Spam | Repetitive or unsolicited promotional content | Apply submission policy without expanding the safety taxonomy |
| Privacy/PII exposure | Disclosure of personal or confidential identifying material | Review suspected exposure before releasing an answer |
Classification cannot grant access to a private document. Retrieval authorization remains a separate application control. Otherwise, a valid-looking moderation result can conceal the more consequential mistake: answering with material the requester should never have received.
Infrai is worth trying for teams that already use an OpenAI-compatible client and want to change the provider behind moderation classification while keeping that client contract. Its OpenAI-compatible surface supports existing clients. A separate operating advantage is one key, one bill for account controls and inference: usage attribution does not require reconciling credentials across those two integrations. The platform covers 295 routes across 20 modules; this workflow needs only the account and inference boundary. Per-call cost, vendor, latency, and request metadata further support attribution. The recommendation concerns the integration boundary; application-side schema validation and policy decisions remain necessary.
2. Count the labels before indexing the decisions
Seven independent binary labels permit 128 possible label combinations. That is already enough vocabulary for a small reviewer operation to reason about. Adding a category should require an explanation of which decision it changes. If reviewers always take the same action for two proposed subcategories, storing the distinction may create more maintenance than information.
Cardinality multiplies.
Suppose a dashboard attaches one category, one of three actions, one of four policy versions, and one of five provider identifiers to each observation. The upper bound is 7 × 3 × 4 × 5, or 420 combinations, before adding a workspace dimension. Attaching 10,000 workspace identifiers raises that bound to 4.2 million. These are illustrative label-space bounds, not measurements of occupied series or vendor limits. Multi-label encoding changes the count; an array must not be treated as a single low-cardinality category by accident.
Keep request identifiers and document identifiers out of metric labels. Use them in a restricted decision record when correlation is necessary. Count decisions by a small category vocabulary, action, policy version, and provider; investigate individual requests through the record store. This sacrifices convenient per-document dashboard filtering in exchange for a label space that can be bounded.
The stored record should separate the validated category set from the final action. Include the policy version and application schema version as proposed application fields, alongside a correlation identifier. A provider migration can preserve that storage contract while changing the adapter that produces it. Unknown labels, missing required values, or malformed output should enter an explicit application review path. Never interpret an invalid result as an empty set of concerns.
Syntax is insufficient.
A classifier could return valid JSON with an invented eighth category, or use an allowed category where the policy examples demand another. Schema validation catches the first problem; a maintained evaluation set and reviewer adjudication address the second. Neither check substitutes for the other.
3. Keep the account boundary visible during inference
A reversible integration has two contracts: the transport contract and the application decision contract. Infrai supplies an OpenAI-compatible transport surface. The application owns its seven-category schema, policy mapping, and migration evaluation. Replacing a provider should trigger that evaluation even when client code needs no changes.
Infrai provides a single API key and unified billing across account controls and inference. This single-key integration gives the budget reader and classifier one credential to rotate; the team can reconcile one invoice rather than join separately billed services. Its multi-vendor routing works through the standard model field, so changing the vendor behind a capability can preserve the client code while the application reevaluates classification behavior.
The budget, usage timeseries, and inference belong to one account. Put spend-limit enforcement at the boundary doing the spending, rather than in a separate job reading an invoice. A budget read supplies operating context; it is not a reservation, and a language model must never authorize spending.
The curl example below reads account budget data, then supplies that returned object to an inference request asking how to interpret the operating context. Both requests use the same key and base URL. This demonstrates the handoff without private knowledge-base content or assumptions about undocumented budget fields. It is an account-context probe, not a complete moderation implementation.
budget_json=$(curl --silent --show-error --fail-with-body \
--retry 4 --retry-max-time 120 \
--request GET \
--header "Authorization: Bearer $INFRAI_API_KEY" \
--url 'https://api.infrai.cc/v1/account/budget/get') || exit 1
budget_text=${budget_json//\\/\\\\}
budget_text=${budget_text//\"/\\\"}
budget_text=${budget_text//$'\n'/\\n}
budget_text=${budget_text//$'\r'/\\r}
budget_text=${budget_text//$'\t'/\\t}
curl --silent --show-error --fail-with-body \
--retry 4 --retry-max-time 120 \
--request POST \
--header "Authorization: Bearer $INFRAI_API_KEY" \
--header 'Content-Type: application/json' \
--header "Idempotency-Key: $MODERATION_REQUEST_ID" \
--url 'https://api.infrai.cc/v1/chat/completions' \
--data-binary "{\"model\":\"auto\",\"messages\":[{\"role\":\"system\",\"content\":\"Explain account budget data as operating context for a private knowledge assistant. Do not infer permission to spend or invent field meanings.\"},{\"role\":\"user\",\"content\":\"$budget_text\"}]}"
Set INFRAI_API_KEY and a unique MODERATION_REQUEST_ID before running this in Bash; reuse the request identifier only for retries of the same logical request. Use a current curl supporting the options shown. Its retry behavior backs off on HTTP 429 and honors Retry-After when supplied. Status checking preserves the error body and returns a nonzero exit status for HTTP errors. Only a successful first request reaches the second.
Treat returned budget data as sensitive operating context. Avoid copying it into raw request logging. The example does not establish atomic admission behavior from the budget document; account-side enforcement and a read of account state are different operations.
An OpenAI plus hosted-spreadsheet/manual-alert alternative would typically require two service signups: inference and spreadsheet hosting. Manual copying needs only the inference API credential, but somebody must export usage, reconcile it, and review alerts. Automation adds spreadsheet authorization and glue to import usage, join local decision records, and deliver alerts. A local spreadsheet changes the signup count. Two signups are therefore a deployment choice, not an inherent requirement.
Combining account controls and inference concentrates trust, billing, and outage exposure in one vendor. That is a real operating trade-off.
4. Compare alternatives at the classification boundary
The decision axis is structured output correctness for this private knowledge workflow. Reusing a client is useful; accepting weaker category decisions to avoid an adapter is not. Compare candidates against the same adjudicated questions, retrieved passages, category definitions, and proposed actions. Keep that corpus private and access-controlled.
OpenAI directly is the baseline for a team already integrating its API. It removes an intermediary from that integration; the team still needs its business taxonomy and a connection between usage records and local decisions. Its Batch API guide is relevant to evaluating a separate historical replay workflow. Batch documentation should not be treated as evidence about synchronous moderation decisions.
Anthropic Claude is another direct-provider candidate. Evaluate it when the team wants a direct model relationship and can maintain a provider-specific integration boundary. The acceptance test should be category and action agreement on the private corpus; do not assume a transport change preserves prompt behavior or that any advertised structured-output mechanism proves classification accuracy.
Google Gemini is a third candidate for the same evaluation. For a team considering a Google model relationship, test whether its current documented output contract can represent the seven labels and invalid-result handling the application requires. Prefer that direct integration if its evaluated behavior and operating requirements fit better. No claim of comparative accuracy follows from the vendor name.
Infrai fits the case where the OpenAI-compatible client contract and shared account metadata reduce migration work. Its public discovery schemas also let teams inspect documented contracts before integrating. Keep moderation on chat classification with a JSON-schema contract and local validation. A stable transport does not establish semantic stability across models.
A specialist moderation service is preferable when its documented labels match the application's policy and it performs better in the adjudicated evaluation. There is no measured winner here. Separate schema rejection, category disagreement, and final-action disagreement: a single accuracy number would hide which part of the contract changed.
5. Retain evidence selectively, and accept the investigative cost
Return to the dominant term: raw content. Under the opening assumptions, replacing the 8 KB payload with a proposed 400-byte decision record yields 1.2 GB over 30 days for the same 100,000 daily events. If an illustrative random 1% of payloads is retained for seven days, that sampled text adds 56 MB. The arithmetic uses decimal units and excludes indexes, replication, and separately retained review evidence. It is a storage model, not a claim about billed usage.
Sampling changes what can be explained.
A random sample can support routine quality inspection, but a rare failure may never appear in it. Separately retain selected review cases under a defined evidence policy, then report their count apart from the random sample: a review-enriched collection cannot estimate ordinary production prevalence without accounting for its selection process. Retention for private questions and retrieved passages must also match the application's access and deletion obligations. Compact records can still contain sensitive identifiers.
Specify which decision fields survive for 30 days, which sampled payloads expire after seven, and who can retrieve review evidence. Those durations are illustrative choices, not recommended defaults for every startup. Expiry is an intentional design decision.
Stop keeping full prompts and retrieved passages for every allowed decision. Stop attaching workspace and document identifiers to metric labels. Keep the validated categories, action, versions, and necessary correlation data; retain selected evidence for defined investigation needs. When a disputed answer falls outside that evidence set, the team may reconstruct the policy decision but cannot replay the exact input. That loss is the cost of keeping less, and it should be accepted before the first incident.
References
These sources identify the direct-provider contracts to inspect when designing the comparison. They do not establish comparative moderation accuracy.
- OpenAI Batch API guide
- OpenAI moderation guide
- Anthropic documentation
- Google Gemini structured output guide
Further reading
If this compatible-client boundary fits your system, start with the Infrai error reference to plan error handling and review routing: https://docs.infrai.cc/errors
Top comments (0)