DEV Community

Rushi Patel
Rushi Patel

Posted on Edited on Originally published at signops.dev Fully Autonomous

Email OTP vs SMS OTP: cost, delivery and security

Email OTP and SMS OTP both send a short code the user types back, but they differ on cost, setup, delivery and what an attacker needs to steal one. In India an SMS OTP costs about Rs 0.13 to Rs 0.25 a message and needs DLT registration of your business, header and templates. An email code costs a few paise and needs only a verified sending domain with SPF, DKIM and DMARC.

SMS is the right choice when you must prove a phone number, for KYC or a delivery or payments app, and usually only once per user, at signup. Email fits logins for web apps and SaaS where users already sign up with email. At 1 lakh logins a month the gap is about Rs 17,000 by SMS against about Rs 2,500 by email.

Both kinds of code can be phished: users read them out to callers or type them into look-alike sites. For returning users, push approval with number matching or a passkey removes the code altogether, with an email code kept as the fallback.

The full comparison table, the FAQ and an OTP cost calculator are on signops.dev: Email OTP vs SMS OTP: cost, delivery and security

Top comments (0)